Role of board
a. Hire and fire CEO
- let CEO run day to day due to lack of information
- if VC board is engaging day to day, important to understand why? Lack of trust or forgot they're not the CEO
b. Make strategic decisions
c. Decide upon compensation
CEO engagement model with board
a. Highlight how board meetings will be run
b. Engagement model with execs
c. Communication of feedback to CEO
- ----- USA specific ------
Business Judgement Rule (BJR)
- Judged on the process of decision making and not the outcome of decision making
- Make sure to approve minutes from previous board meeting
BJR means burden of proof lies with the plaintiff
Entire Fairness
If bad faith allegation emerges then burden of proof lies with the accused
If proven guilty, duty of loyalty is violated and personal liability kicks in.
Trados case
Management Incentive Programme carve out due to acquisition
Two reasons why BJR didn't work
a. Liquidation preferences conflict with common stockholders
b. VC time opportunity cost model
For executive on board representing common, if they get asymmetric and material proceeds not accessible by common, then they are in conflict
Lessons from Trados case
- Assume you'll be under entire fairness
- Hire banker for quotes and fairness opinion
- Think through MIP carefully
- Make sure board acknowledges fiduciary responsibility and has common shareholders at the back of mind
Pull up clause to let investors retain some liquidation preferences
Lessons from Bloodhound case
- Even if financing internally, get external price validation
- Don't tie stock option grants too close to internal financing. Get compensation consultant